Does Your Private Club Board Meet Too Often?
My wife just asked me to be on a marketing committee for another board. She loves animals and she is on the board of the county’s humane society. Well, she serves two boards for the humane society – the board and then the foundation board. Two meetings this week. She came home complaining about the time these meetings take.
When I asked her what the role, definition and parameters of the marketing committee might be, she mentioned that we could get into the nitty gritty of marketing for the humane society. “Don’t they have someone on staff that can action the marketing plan?” I asked. She answered meekly: “Not really.”
Every situation is different. And a Florida county humane society’s board is quite different in perspective from a private club board. Or is it? They are both usually non-profits. They both supervise CEO’s and COO’s. They are both filled with volunteers and they both have committees, also comprised of volunteers. Volunteerism is a wonderful notion, but it has its limitations when it comes to boards.
I have served as a club president, on countless private club boards and community action groups – I loved my ten years on the board of Big Brothers, Big Sisters – but even with my strongest urges not to manage, that urge as a businessman comes up and I fight it all along the journey of volunteering. The very expertise that makes someone a valuable board member can also make that person a dangerous micromanager.
In my decades of serving on boards, here are a few nuggets for you to take back to your private club.
Define The Role of Every Committee
As I outlined above, too often a committee becomes a mini-management team. The greens committee wants to manage the Director of Agronomy while the house committee knows best what to put on a new menu. And, the membership committee gets into the files of day-to-day membership administration. I’ve always been a believer that less is more, and the fewer standing committees a club has, I believe the stronger the governance.
Each committee should have a written charter defining its purpose, its authority, and its reporting responsibilities. And, perhaps, most importantly, the written charter should outline the committee’s relationship with management. This distinction, and true definition, is what a committee is all about: advising and recommending. Of course it’s easy to say, and the art of putting this into practice lies at the heart of how a strong board should operate. Committees advise and recommend. Management executes. The board governs. Any delegated decision-making authority should be expressly defined, if at all.
Require a Written Committee Report Before Every Board Meeting
When I run a business, I look for communication prior to any meeting. Outline the meeting’s agenda and goals. Otherwise, it can quickly become an amiable and aimless chat. Human nature is to procrastinate and I’m never surprised by the 10pm call from a committee chair the night before a planned board meeting. What I ask of committees is four-fold within a written report produced at least seven days in advance:
- What has the committee accomplished since the last meeting.
- What is the current main goal and other actionable items.
- What decisions or resources does the committee require from the full board.
- What are the committee’s goals and objectives before the next board meeting.
What I do stress is that these reports are circulated five to seven days before the board meeting and are not regurgitated at the meeting.
Let Board Members Determine What Warrants Discussion
This is where governance is truly a group effort. I’ve always maintained twelve minds are more powerful than one president. Once the committee reports are circulated, board members can identify what is warranted to discuss. The board president and general manager can then establish the meeting’s agenda based on those governors’ requests, required approvals and strategic priorities. This harkens of a consent agenda, something I always pushed for as a corporate executive. The practice allows for non-controversial approvals being grouped and handled together – if there is an item that a board member feels warrants a discussion, it can be pulled outside of the grouping. But if there are no questions about the golf committee’s report, why should a board hear it read at a meeting?

Make Shared Digital Workspaces Mandatory
Every committee should operate within a common, secure digital space such as Google Drive, Dropbox, or a board portal, such as BellesBoard. In this secure space rests the committee charters, committee and board minutes, budgets, relevant historical data and decisions, project timelines, pending recommendations and action items. What is so important in this shared space is the idea of transparency. All committee and board members can see the information without having to ask a controller or owner of a spreadsheet.
Getting at the heart of volunteerism is also the high turnover of committee chairs and board members. Having a shared space for club governance allows leadership change while maintaining institutional knowledge.
Replace Status Updates with Decisions and Accountability
A board agenda should identify the differences between presentation, discussion and formal decision making. A strong, organized agenda can push the board through its own organizational structure. After any board meeting, it is management’s responsibility to action the items voted upon, upload the decisions, data and approvals to the shared space, and identify deadlines and persons responsible. What I dislike most in board meetings? When the next board meeting simply rediscovers what was decided at the previous one!
Who Says a Board Should Meet Monthly
Well some club by-laws do and some states might in connection with a non-profit board. And, fiduciary responsibilities will still lie with the full board. The executive committee can’t replace the full board through delegation. But, if a club could operate effectively with eleven board meetings instead of twelve, why couldn’t it operate with eight? Or six? The question shouldn’t be how many meetings have been traditionally held, but how many meetings effective governance actually requires.
Perhaps a meeting of the executive committee twice a year, during the less busy governance times, might suffice and be a better brain-storming session than 12 full governors around a board table. And think of this: every hour a general manager spends preparing for an unnecessary meeting is an hour not spent managing the club, its employees, and the member experience.
Historically, private club boards have met an average of 10.5 times per year. But in an era of secure, shared digital workspaces, video conferencing, email, text messaging, and collaborative platforms such as Microsoft Teams and Slack, is the traditional monthly board meeting still necessary? So much of the reporting, communication, and preparation that once required everyone to gather around a conference table can now take place between meetings. Perhaps it’s time for boards to reconsider not only how they conduct their meetings, but how often they really need to meet.
Again, less is more. Perhaps even one fewer board meeting would make the others that much more significant and better attended.
Governance efficiency is truly important to move a private club forward. It’s not so much the time spent at each meeting, it’s the agenda and progression. If a strong agenda can shift a board meeting from repetitive reporting to capital planning, financial oversight, leadership development and long-term strategy, the club reaps reward from strong governance. For when committee reports are rehashed at a board meeting, when does a board find the time to govern?
Ed Shanaphy is President of SBW Associates, Inc., the parent company of Beyond The Baselines, now in its 18th year advising and managing private clubs across the United States. His extensive experience in club governance includes serving as President of Blackheath Rugby and Lawn Tennis Club in London, where he helped guide the historic institution through the transition to professional rugby in England in 1995, working alongside the International Rugby Board. He has also served on the boards of Cumberland Lawn Tennis Club in Hampstead, London, and Big Brothers Big Sisters of Indian River County, Florida. Before founding SBW Associates, Shanaphy spent 19 years as Chief Operating Officer of Haysbridge (UK) Ltd., a major European media and advertising company with operations in London, Dublin, and Sydney. A founding partner of The Half Bottle of Wine Company, he was also named one of two finalists for Ernst & Young’s UK Entrepreneur of the Year, alongside fashion designer LK Bennett. Shanaphy has served as Chief Operating Officer, General Manager, and senior advisor to numerous private clubs. He currently serves on the board of BTB Heroes Foundation Corp., the charitable organization behind the national BTB Heroes Tour, which raises funds to support veterans and military families through competitive tennis events.


Leave a Reply